?

Log in

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Mokie and Bik by Wendy Orr

Last night, I read a book which came highly recommended to me by the lovely and talented Linda Urban (aka lurban). The book? Mokie and Bik by Wendy Orr, illustrated by Mr. Bean. Okay, illustrated by Mr. Jonathan Bean, but you know he must hear it from more than me, right?

Mokie and Bik is a chapter book. As the cleverest among you have already guessed, a chapter book is not a picture book or easy reader, or I'd have said so. And by definition, a chapter book has chapters. Because I've told you there's an illustrator, you have probably guessed that there are illustrations. With the exception of the cover, which has color art, the interior art is pen and ink drawings that are only in black and white.

In somewhat unconventional lay terms, chapter books are the gateway drug into novels. They are a way to ease kids into longer stories once they've gotten their reading legs under them through the use of easy readers. They are often humorous, and they include those illustrations that we just mentioned to offer visual clues that help emerging readers feel confident that they've sorted out the story. Chapter books can include things like easy wordplay, something that many kids love, particularly now that they're feeling they've got a handle on words. And they usually have somewhere in the neighborhood of 10 shortish chapters. The kids notice the 10, not the shortish, and it helps them build confidence.

Popular chapter book characters include Judy Moody, The Magic Treehouse kids, the Boxcar Children, Junie B. Jones, and Clarice Bean. And from now on, I believe they'll include Mokie and Bik.

The actual review:

Mokie and Bik are twins with highly unusual names. One is male, and one is female, and it took me a while to sort out which name went with which kid (as in, I really had no clue for a while, and then when I heard it, I didn't find the selections intuitive, and had a hard time sorting out who was who unless I was assisted by pronouns, which sometimes, I wasn't). Because I loved some other things about the book so much, I am feeling forgiving of that particular pitfall.



Mokie and Bik lived on a boat called Bullfrog. They lived in it, on it, all around it—monkeying up
  ladders
    and
      down
        ropes,
over the wheelhouse and across the cabin floor.
"Twins!" their mother shouted, because the lines of her Art jiggled and jarred
when Mokie and Bik played bumpboats—
  bump thump rumpboats
  up and down the wheelhouse,
  bump thump rumping
  from the steering drawers
  to the bouncy bunk,
  mump clump gumping
  from sleepdog Laddie
  to the potbelly hotter.
"Get out from underfoot!"
So Bik bumped Mokie out the door—
splat!—into nanny Ruby’s bucket as she was sploshing the deck.
"Twins!" shouted Ruby. "Get out from underfoot!"


You have just read the complete text of the first two pages of text in the book, each of which is accompanied by artwork, so in truth, you just covered four pages of the book. And in those four pages, you've learned most of the premise of the story and met most of the characters as well. The mother is kind of like Mrs. Casson from Hilary McKay's stories for older readers: an artist who likes some time to herself, and says things like "Ask me no questions and I'll tell you no lies" when she takes off alone on her botormike. (No, that was not a typo. It's how the word appears in the book.) The twins have a bunch of time to themselves, and they alternate between useful tasks like posing on one foot and carrying fish for Erik the Viking.

Each of the chapters tells a story involving Mokie and Bik and some of the adventures and interactions with the people and animals in their world. The later chapters build on some of the knowledge found in the earlier ones, but in truth, the chapters don't really rely on one another the same way that a novel does. Neither are they separate short stories with common characters. It's more episodic, the same way that Winnie-the-Pooh was, or The Wind in the Willows.

I like the whimsy of the stories in the chapters of this book, which is tempered by enough practicality to keep the book from skidding off into a cesspool of irretrievable cuteness. I adore Orr's use of language, which includes a playfulness that is not found nearly often enough in writing for this age group (in my opinion). Her use of mixed-up phrasing doesn't ruffle my grammatical feathers the way Barbara Park's does in the Junie B. Jones books, since she goes for substituted words ("fisk" instead of fish, which is actually explained at one point) or misplaced words ("parrots" for "pirates", and vice-versa, resulting in this bit of information about the twins' absent father: "'He's a parrot,' said Bik. 'He'll come home with a pirate on his shoulder.'")

I like that when one of the twins ends up in danger partway through the book, the twins solve their own problem, but afterwards, the adults step in to assure things won't go wrong again by making sure the twins learn how to swim. And I like that each of the chapters tells its own episode of a story.

The one thing that I didn't like was that many of the chapters had "slight" endings. Now, on the one hand, this is a chapter book, and not a series of short stories, so the chapters don't require "final endings". In fact, the endings should make you want to turn the page to read the next chapter. But many of the chapter conclusions consisted of single-paragraph (and sometimes single-sentence) summation of the "point" of the chapter, and others kind of just ended, and both events were something that bothered me, although I cannot put my finger on what it was I wanted them to do, aside from "be more satisfying." The end of the book as a whole, however, was extremely satisfying, and so my final conclusion is that I LOVE THIS BOOK. And that it makes me want to play with language in new and different ways as a poet and author.

HEARTILY recommended to young independent readers and as a read-aloud to emerging readers, since parents are sure to enjoy these characters as well. I can't wait for the next Mokie and Bik adventure. How do I know there'll be more? Well, there's a number "1" on the top of the spine. Plus, through the clever use of Henry Holt's online catalogue, I found Mokie and Bik Go to Sea is on the Spring 2008 list. Something to look forward to!





Site Meter

Comments

( 12 comments — Leave a comment )
lurban
Jan. 5th, 2008 10:35 pm (UTC)
Oh I KNEW you'd love it! Isn't the language play wonderful? I didn't find it "cute" either -- it felt very organic, the way kids in families (and twins especially) develop their own names for things and patterns of speaking that become so natural for that they couldn't be said any other way.
kellyrfineman
Jan. 6th, 2008 05:01 pm (UTC)
I adored the wordplay and the way that her word choices were made accessible to kids, but were by no means "dumbed down" for them. And I really loved the characters and the stories. I'll be interested to see how she sustains the same story and writing levels in the books to come. And hopefully, I will be able to recall which name goes with the boy and which with the girl.
writerjenn
Jan. 5th, 2008 11:49 pm (UTC)
Just had to thank you for the phrase, "a cesspool of irretrievable cuteness."
kellyrfineman
Jan. 6th, 2008 05:00 pm (UTC)
You are most welcome. I was pretty pleased with that particular turn of phrase myself!
crissachappell
Jan. 6th, 2008 08:13 pm (UTC)
beautiful
kellyrfineman
Jan. 7th, 2008 03:49 am (UTC)
As is your book cover. :)
crissachappell
Jan. 7th, 2008 03:53 am (UTC)
Thanks! (I had nothing to do with it!) ;)
ex_lgburns
Jan. 6th, 2008 08:38 pm (UTC)
Great minds!
I just read this to my kids, on Linda's recommendation, and planned to blog about it today. Instead I am just going to send my readers here to read your thorough review!

The "slight" chapter endings worked for me, if only because they felt so true to the characters of Mokie and Bik ... boisterous and fearless, with so much to see and do that there is only a speck of time left over for carrying their adventures (and plot lines) to completion.

This feels like a virtual Book Discussion Group ...

Loree

kellyrfineman
Jan. 7th, 2008 03:49 am (UTC)
Re: Great minds!
But, but, I like to read your reviews!
ex_lgburns
Jan. 7th, 2008 11:38 am (UTC)
Re: Great minds!
Oh, I only need the slightest excuse to shirk my duties ...

(And calling my blog posts reviews scares me; they're, um, meandering responses to the books I read. Definitely not reviews. Yes. That works better.)
(Anonymous)
Jan. 10th, 2008 04:03 am (UTC)
Mokie and Bik review
Thank you for this lovely, but more importantly, thoughtful, considered and well-written review. (Well, okay, of course I care that it's so positive, but I truly would like to think that I care about the thoughtful discussion - like the difference of opinion as to whether I should have given each chapter a stronger ending. (I've been thinking about it, and now I don't know what I think. I tend to work in a fairly intuitive way and that was what felt right for me at the time.)

What's really important to me with this book is that people are getting the language. It was SO hard; took me about 4 years to work out the structure of the book itself, and then how I could suggest a twin language that I hoped readers could work out, possibly with the aid of the illustrations. (The real twins think their language was made up of quite a lot of the different languages they heard on the docks, as well as the usual mispronunciations - fisk, Norwegian for fish, is the one word in the book that they probably did use.)

Thanks for taking so much trouble - and I love the way it's turned into a book discussion group at the end!

best
Wendy Orr
kellyrfineman
Jan. 10th, 2008 01:51 pm (UTC)
Re: Mokie and Bik review
As a reader, it is sometimes easy to look at something and form an opinion, but impossible to say what, exactly, should be different. And that was the case here: even though I could say that some of the chapters could have had stronger endings, I couldn't for the life of me advocate actually changing a word, because I found the book so, so charming.
( 12 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

May 2017
S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031   

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com