Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Sense & Sensibility, Volume I, chapter 17

Edward accompanies the younger Misses Dashwood back to Barton Cottage, where Mrs Dashwood is delighted (if surprised) to see him. Edward didn't send a message ahead that he was coming, you see, which is rather thoughtless of him, really.

I really appreciate this bit of narration that opens the chapter. The italics were added by me:

Mrs Dashwood was surprised only for a moment at seeing him; for his coming to Barton was, in her opinion, of all things the most natural. Her joy and expression of regard long outlived her wonder. He received the kindest welcome from her; and shyness, coldness, reserve could not stand against such a reception. They had begun to fail him before he entered the house, and they were quite overcome by the captivating manners of Mrs Dashwood. Indeed a man could not very well be in love with either of her daughters, without extending the passion to her; and Elinor had the satisfaction of seeing him soon become more like himself. His affections seemed to reanimate towards them all, and his interest in their welfare again became perceptible. He was not in spirits, however; he praised their house, admired its prospect, was attentive, and kind; but still he was not in spirits. The whole family perceived it, and Mrs Dashwood, attributing it to some want of liberality in his mother, sat down to table indignant against all selfish parents.

We are reminded how very enthusiastic Mrs D can be about seeing people she likes, and you can just picture Edward defrosting as the warmth of her welcome washes over him. I especially like the sentence I added italics to - it makes plain how easy it is to love Mrs Dashwood, but the narrator here also strongly implies that Edward is in love with Elinor. Is it a mistake on Austen's part to put this here when it's never been established as fact, or is it a deliberate choice to tip the reader that this is so when the characters themselves are uncertain? I have no clear answer, but boy, do I hope it's the second.

Throughout this scene, we see that Edward is somewhat lacking in spirits and seems prone to become lost in thought. Marianne's accusation of him being "reserved" at the end of the chapter seem to send him off into a melancholy reverie. Clearly, something is weighing on Edward's mind. I can say for certain that when I first read this chapter, I discounted Austen's representation of a pensive Edward and was quick to accept Mrs Dashwood's conclusion that it's all related to his mother, but looking at it again now, it seems plain that there's something else going on besides anything to do with his mother.

I especially like the conversation about money in the middle of the chapter, which begins with Marianne's question to Edward:

"What have wealth or grandeur to do with happiness?"

"Grandeur has but little," said Elinor, "but wealth has much to do with it."

"Elinor, for shame!" said Marianne, "money can only give happiness where there is nothing else to give it. Beyond a competence, it can afford no real satisfaction, as far as mere self is concerned."

"Perhaps," said Elinor, smiling, "we may come to the same point. Your competence and my wealth are very much alike, I dare say; and without them, as the world goes now, we shall both agree that every kind of external comfort must be wanting. Your ideas are only more noble than mine. Come, what is your competence?"

"About eighteen hundred or two thousand a year; not more than that."

Elinor laughed. "Two thousand a year! One is my wealth! I guessed how it would end."

First off, a reminder as to what a "competence" is (per the Merriam Webster dictionary): "A sufficiency of means for the necessities and conveniences of life". In other words, it is the minimum amount required for a married couple to support themselves and their family. Marianne claims she needs about two thousand pounds per year as a competence (i.e., just to get by on), whereas Elinor believes that she'd have plenty to get by on (with some to spare) at only half that amount. We shall see if they each get at least what they claim to seek by the end of the book!

Now let us leave Edward to brood a bit until tomorrow, when we get a further hint as to what he may be brooding about.

Kiva - loans that change lives
Site Meter


( 7 comments — Leave a comment )
Oct. 20th, 2010 11:11 pm (UTC)
What is it with these Edwards and their brooding! heh!

I liked Edward a lot more in this chapter - especially with his teasing Marianne about what she'd buy with a fortune.
Oct. 21st, 2010 12:17 am (UTC)
I especially like his line about being 'saucy.' Oh, Edward, you saucy minx.
(Deleted comment)
Oct. 21st, 2010 12:21 am (UTC)
You are correct - the savvy reader has sensed, along with the characters, that Edward feels something for Elinor, but there's an impediment. I love that Austen flat-out implies/asserts it in that line, however. In her later work, she's more subtle than that. Still, as she was trying to make a point about how warm and lovable Mrs D is, I suppose we can all forgive her.

And I meant to point out that the discussion of fortune (and the lack thereof) that goes on in Edward's presence - and largely because Elinor instigates it - shows how very "intimate" an acquaintance she considers him. One simply did not discuss such things with anyone but the closest of acquaintances, and I rather expect she'd have frowned on such a discussion taking place with Sir John and Mrs Jennings, yet here she is, starting it.
(Deleted comment)
Oct. 21st, 2010 12:23 am (UTC)
Although the point of Austen's book is actually the relationship between the two sisters and their needs to mediate their behavior - Marianne needing a much larger dose of sense and Elinor needing to let loose with a bit of sensibility (feeling) - she writes a mean romance and an excellent mystery as well. No wonder she's still considered a master, whereas the romance knock-offs don't hold up. (They lack the gravitas of Austen's books somehow.)
Oct. 28th, 2010 04:04 am (UTC)
**** sitting here brooding about my competence now ****
Oct. 28th, 2010 03:42 pm (UTC)
I wish the competence we had were a bit higher just now.
( 7 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

May 2018


Powered by LiveJournal.com