?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

This chapter could be subtitled "The Dashwood Sisters go to London." Of course, it only covers their travel time, arrival and first day, but still . . .

Picking up on where I left off with Mrs Jennings

How sweet is it that Mrs Jennings fusses over them so much? I know she's a chatty old lady and all, but I still love her. The only thing that has her unhappy in the slightest is that the Dashwoods are letting her order all their meals at the inns they stop at along the way to London (an expense that Mrs Jennings is undoubtedly picking up, including their room rentals as they go - when she said it'd only cost her the price of sending her servant by a more public conveyance, she wasn't entirely truthful). Mrs Jennings really, truly wants to make the Dashwood girls as happy as possible, which includes feeding them things that they love, and she is frustrated that they won't be more forthcoming about their preferences. *love*

Marianne is a bit of a bitch here

You will recall that Marianne is the one who is so enthusiastic about going to London, but as we immediately see, it is entirely because she hopes to see Willoughby there. Her single-mindedness on the issue - indeed, her complete fixation on Willoughby - begins to be more apparent, as she is rude to other people (completely ignoring Mrs Jennings during three days of travel time - in a closed carriage! - and then snubbing Colonel Brandon when he pays a call on them their first evening in town) and inattentive to pretty much anything else, be it food, books, conversation or even shopping.

Not cool, Marianne. Not cool at all.

When the Dashwoods get to London, the very first thing Marianne does is send a note off to Willoughby. The fact that Marianne is writing a letter to Willoughby is perceived by Elinor as evidence that they are engaged, since correspondence between unmarried people of the opposite gender was limited at the time to relatives, spouses, or those who were betrothed. She isn't good company for anyone - not even Elinor - pacing and making herself somewhat crazy because she's waiting to hear from Willoughby.

Elinor keeps on keeping on

Meanwhile, I'd like to talk about Elinor here. She is headed off to London against her wishes, knowing that there's some chance she will be forced into company with Edward, whom she loves but can never, ever have. And yet, although she is the one who we are certain is in dire circumstances, she's the one who goes out of her way to be kind to Mrs Jennings, talking with her, playing cards with her and her friends, etc. She is doing her duty, despite personal hardship, while her sister . . . is sooooo not. Meanwhile, she's worried about her sister, since Marianne seems too wrapped up in Willoughby thoughts - and Elinor's spider senses have been tingling about Willoughby, to the point that she actively distrusts his motives and/or intentions.

She ends the chapter thinking that something is rotten in the state of Denmark, since Willoughby seems not to reciprocate Marianne's feelings: if he loves Marianne and is (she believes) engaged to her, why on earth hasn't he turned up to say hello?

A word about the menfolk:

When they arrive, Marianne sends a note directly to Willoughby. We have to assume, since it's so short, that it's along the lines of "I'm here in London, here's my address, come as soon as you can." And Marianne is certain that will get an immediate response.

It is not, however, Willoughby who arrives with all due haste; rather, it is Colonel Brandon, who heard from the Palmers that they would be arriving and paid a call on them the very day they arrived in town - which is hasty indeed. Seriously, turning up the next day to pay a call would be considered quick, so turning up the very day that they got to town shows real desire to see them.

For Marianne to be visibly upset that it's he, and not Willoughby, who has come to call, exiting the room in order to get her feelings under anything at all resembling control - well, poor Brandon. I just want to reach into the pages of the book and pat his hand or something.

So you've got Willoughby, who is not responding to a direct invitation, compared to Brandon, who races over as soon as he hears they're in town. (I'll say it again - Colonel Brandon: Man of Action). Oh, Austen, how I love your combination of foreshadowing and character development. You, madam, are a genius.

Kiva - loans that change lives
Site Meter

Comments

( 13 comments — Leave a comment )
robinellen
Nov. 3rd, 2010 04:29 pm (UTC)
How can we not love Colonel Brandon? He's an amazing character, and in many ways, far too good for Marianne ;)
kellyrfineman
Nov. 3rd, 2010 05:12 pm (UTC)
He loves her more than she deserves, yes? I can't quite understand why he loves her so much, since she's not always nice to him. But I believe it's a combination of his nostalgia for his (dead) first love and his admiration of her wholeheartedness about everything. When Marianne plays, she's always "all in", isn't she?
mostly_irish
Nov. 3rd, 2010 05:49 pm (UTC)
I just have to say...I always loved Col. Brandon but when he was played by Alan Rickman my adoration was heightened even more. Man of Action indeed...rawr!
kellyrfineman
Nov. 3rd, 2010 09:18 pm (UTC)
He is sosososo yummy. And not just in that role, but especially in that role. David Morrissey was pretty delicious in the 2008 BBC/PBS version, though.
rachelswardrobe
Nov. 3rd, 2010 07:39 pm (UTC)
Much as Marianne is badly behaved, I think it comes as the result of her really obsessive, almost unhealthy love for willoughby. Mind you she's mean to Brandon before Willoughby is even on the scene. I like to think she's just young and like a lot of young people rather introspective, once she's experienced a bit more of the world she seems to redeem herself somewhat.
kellyrfineman
Nov. 3rd, 2010 09:19 pm (UTC)
Oh, I'm not saying she won't work to redeem herself. Just that she's a truly self-absorbed train wreck at present - and, of course, it's only going to get worse as Austen explores what happens if you let your emotions run loose.
rachelswardrobe
Nov. 3rd, 2010 10:46 pm (UTC)
I think I feel more sympathetic towards her because I've seen the film more recently than read the book... she comes across much better on screen : )
kellyrfineman
Nov. 3rd, 2010 11:30 pm (UTC)
I said just that thing to midnightblooms below - too funny!
midnightblooms
Nov. 3rd, 2010 07:44 pm (UTC)
You have now reached the part of the story where every page ends with me wanting to slap Marianne. Hard. First time I read S&S, I got so irritated with her, I switched to Mansfield Park.

Col. Brandon is such a good guy, but he is, sadly, overlooked when talking about dreamy guys in the literary world. (Just as he is cast aside for Willowby, readers go on and on about Mr. Darcy while Brandon's is rarely mentioned. I'm guilty of this, too.) He's so unassuming and decent and dependable. My heart just breaks for him every time Marianne treats him with contempt.

And yes, mostly_irish, Alan Rickman as Brandon is rawr indeed!
kellyrfineman
Nov. 3rd, 2010 09:23 pm (UTC)
Too funny - at JASNA meetings, Brandon is universally loved, along with Darcy, Mr. Knightley, Captain Wentworth, and Henry Tilney. In fact, I know someone who gave their child the middle name of Brandon after the good Colonel.

I know just what you mean about wanting to slap Marianne - and it only gets worse before it gets better. She's far more pitiable in the screen versions than in the book itself, really.

And as I responded to mostly_irish, Alan Rickman is yummy in everything, and especially as Brandon. (Although I liked David Morrissey's Brandon quite a bit, too - and he actual duels with Willoughby on screen - *swoon*).
melted_rachel
Nov. 8th, 2010 01:53 pm (UTC)
Poor Brandon :(

It's so good getting back to reading S&S again - I'm using the chapters and your notes as treats for every chunk I manage to write today.
kellyrfineman
Nov. 8th, 2010 03:35 pm (UTC)
Poor Brandon indeed.

I love your plan - I hope you manage to get a lot of writing done!
melted_rachel
Nov. 8th, 2010 03:41 pm (UTC)
Thanks! And you too! :D I seem to have gone beyond my enthusiastic stage - now I have to use bribes! Last year I watched Mystery Science Theatre 3000 clips as treats - this year I'm trying to be much more educational!
( 13 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

December 2018
S M T W T F S
      1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031     

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com