Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Emma, Volume I, Chapter 8

I hope you'll forgive me for the shortness of today's post. In a later one, I'll explain more about the "whys" of it, but for now, trust me when I say that I don't have a longer one in me. Before I get to the actual post, let me point out that Emma's behavior in this chapter is so upsetting to men of good sense everywhere that Captain Wentworth was distraught on learning of her remarks.

The very best thing I could think of to share with you is actually this clip from the 1995 film production of Emma starring the dishy Jeremy Northam as Mr Knightley to Gwyneth Paltrow's Emma Woodhouse. The important bits of dialogue - and several of my favorites of Mr Knightley's quotes - are included in the archery scene that replaces the parlour scene Austen crafted. I love the way the hits and misses of both shooters provides additional commentary/subtext here. The clip opens with some of Emma's and Harriet's conversation about Robert Martin, then proceeds to the conversation between Emma and Mr Knightley. If you do not wish to move ahead, I suggest stopping the clip once Mr Knightley walks off, somewhere around the 5:33 mark.

I will say that Austen's proto-feminism is showing in this scene, as Emma seethes about men, who are only interested in a pretty face and a pleasing disposition. Mr Knightley (one of Austen's two favorites of her own heroes) argues to the contrary, saying that Emma's views on what men want in their wives is balderdash. The thing is, they are both right: Some men of the time valued beauty and disposition over intelligence and education, so Emma is not entirely wrong - and certainly any prospective spouse (male or female) would probably prefer someone nice-looking and good-natured to someone hideous and/or cross.

Harriet has her looks and temperament going for her, but she comes up way short on intelligence, education, and plain old good sense - as Mr Knightley is quick to point out. Still, he reckoned that since Robert Martin was so desperately in love with her and is himself a rational, clever man, he'd be able to manage with a pretty, foolish wife whom he loved. (My - Harriet has rather a lot in common with Mrs Bennet from Pride and Prejudice, come to think of it - low connections (lower than Mrs Bennet's, actually), beauty but little intelligence or education. Harriet, however, is good-natured and not inclined to hypochondria. But I digress.)

It's really Mr Knightley's arguments that express Austen's protofeminism. He argues that (rational) men want rational wives, not just pretty airheads, and he denies Emma's accusation that men expect women to accept any offer of marriage that comes their way. In response to Emma's teasing that Harriet would be the perfect spouse for Mr Knightley, were he inclined to marry, Mr Knightley reasserts his earlier position that no good will come from Emma's and Harriet's relationship: he believes that Emma will puff Harriet up so far that she won't look at any one who might be willing to marry her, but that Harriet will eventually want to marry, and wil end up settling for someone far worse than Robert Martin, all as a result of Emma's meddling.

Gosh, I love this chapter. It's one of my favorites in the entire book. Heck, it's among my favorites in all of Austen, really.

Kiva - loans that change lives
Site Meter



( 5 comments — Leave a comment )
May. 20th, 2011 06:30 pm (UTC)
Mine too! And "better to be with out sense than missapply it as you do." one of my favorite quotes ever.
May. 20th, 2011 08:12 pm (UTC)
I love that one. And "Men of sense, whatever you may choose to say, do not want silly wives!"

Edited at 2011-05-20 08:12 pm (UTC)
Jun. 2nd, 2011 08:46 pm (UTC)
So now I'm curious - what is Robert Martin's social level? And, according to Mr. Knightly, he has very good manners, not at all like a 'farmer' would have. Mr. Knightly even calls him a 'gentleman-farmer'. Do you know what that's all about?
Jun. 3rd, 2011 02:13 am (UTC)
According to Mr Knightley, Robert Martin is a "gentleman-farmer" and Mr Knightley considers him a friend. We know that his sisters have been sent to Mrs Goddard's school, so it's not like they're part of the laboring class - and Harriet emphasizes that they have TWO parlors. Also, Emma mentions that Robert Martin is in the in-between - too low to mix with her, but not low enough to need her help.

It sounds very much to me like Robert is a gentleman, albeit one without a terribly high income or much in the way of social status - the sort who needs to run his farm in order to earn money. Emma's decision not to mix with him is nonsense, of course.
Jun. 3rd, 2011 11:27 pm (UTC)
So, maybe just a little bit lower than the Bennets, and probably on par with the Coles, who earned their money in trade. Emma's snobbery is, as you say, nonsense.
( 5 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

December 2018


Powered by LiveJournal.com